yeah, this is the other one. "i hate the way you don't appreciate the smiths...and morrissey" - i'm well aware brand new is massively influenced by the smiths but despite this they don't sound anything like each other, on this album Jesse Lacey comes across in a far more Nirvana esque, melodramatic, typically, well, American way than his idol does on the queen is dead, but the album doesn't suffer - if anything, without the wit and humour of the smiths, brand new's album is far darker and abstract (as opposed to the all too real sentiments expressed on the former) and in that sense there's no point drawing too many comparisons between my two favourite albums (convenient :p). anyway.
this is another classic, but for sure that's a far less universal opinion in this case. brand new is one of those bands whose evolution has practically mirrored my own tastes in music to a certain extent, and it's always cool to see what changes they'll make to their sound - it's not experimental or anything but let's face it, a band you already like changing their sound is more exciting than a new band with a crazy sound you have to hear. sure, it may be very good, but seeing what a band you already like will do is just better.
this is the biggest jump they've made so far between albums, trading in the acoustic, gentle take on "the scene" for alt rock influences, and the album relies on a slow, gradual build most of time - tracks like "limousine" and "luca" aren't going to jump at you straight away but brand new mastered building up tension to the "big" moments on this album (one highlight is the haunting, quiet backing vocals at the climax of the aforementioned "limousine" - look up the lyrics). i feel with the follow up, "daisy", brand new tweaked this sound rather than changing up their sound per se, but they definitely perfected that formula here - mumbling depressive/impassioned screaming bipolar vocals (but not in a goofy system of a down way), driving drums and bass, and atmospheric guitars clash to great effect here. genius (yeah i said it!).